Brussels, EUBrussels, EUWashington, DC Rue de la Cible 50, 1030 Brussels +32 471 77 94 52 info@saper-vedere.eu 400 Seventh Street, NW - Suite 406 Washington, DC 20004 +1 202 292 4600 washington@saper-vedere.eu

This morning, Jean-Claude Juncker, President of the European Commission delivered the annual State of the European Union speech. It’s intention is to inform Europeans where the EU currently is and where it will go in the coming months.

The Brussels bubble

It really exists

People from Brussels were the most active to talk about the speech

England, Catalonia and Scotland

top 10 regions

England, Catalonia and Scotland are among the top 10 regions where the speech was discussed

Sentiment in the UK

More negative

The overall sentiment expressed in the UK was more negative than in other countries

Marine Le Pen

Most retweeted tweet

After the speech, the most retweeted tweet from all over Europe was from Marine Le Pen

‘Brexit’, ‘UK’ and ‘Single Market’

most prevalent keywords

Semantic analysis shows that ‘Brexit’, ‘UK’ and ‘Single Market’ were the most prevalent keywords used soteu

 

Timeline

The graph shows the timeline of the speech and where the volume of tweets hit their cruising speed. The peaks correspond to the different announcements made by Mr Juncker and the reaction to them. Because the tweet rate decreased shortly after each announcement was made, it shows that the discussions are mostly held by journalists.

 

Semantic analysis

Keyword analysis

Disclaimer : Only tweets in English and French were analysed in this section

Regarding the overall number of mentions through articles and tweets, we notice that there is a significant representation of the Brexit issue. Other than Brexit, the keywords are mainly neutral. Following the theme of the Brexit issue, let’s focus on what the keywords in the UK were:

 
We can see that the Essex story and Brexit are more prevalent there.
 
Concerning the overall sentiment of Mr Juncker’s speech, we analysed the difference between the positive and negative keywords.
 
 

NB : Tonality algorithm are not 100 % trustworthy and could be twisted. However comparing 2 different results from the same algorithm is a good indicator.

 
 

Top tweets

At the end of the speech, here were the Top 5 Tweets, ranked by number of RTs :

 
 
We clearly see there that the Top 5 tweets are tweets sent by EU institutions. Interestingly, there is no journalist, politician or citizen featured. This shows clearly that, with regards to discussions, the power of the EU institutions is even bigger than the power of the people who run them.
 
Marine Le Pen is the only politician in this top 5 having local political responsibilities, showing that she has a lot more engagement than others. She even has more engagement on this subject than any of the EU institutions or Jean-Claude Juncker himself. Guy Verhofstadt, a well known politician in European affairs, is also featured there.
 

Demographics

Gender analysis

There were more men commenting and reacting to the State of the Union than women.

Nb : Gender repartition is based on first names

Interest analysis

Unsurprisingly, journalists, people engaged and interested in politics as well as business are well represented.

Nb : Centre of interests are defined by scanning account description and tweet activity

Further breakdown by profession also shows that a Brussels bubble specialised in consulting, journalism or entrepreneurship exists.

From the political community, EU’s existential crisis was a key topic.

Quite logically, privacy issues and 5G were more discussed in the tech community whereas the Brexit was very central in the economic community.

Geographic analysis

At a national level, we can see there were significantly more participants taking part from the United Kingdom, followed by Belgium and France.

Nb : Countries are obtained through GNIP datas for Twitter and journalist/blogger website (Source : Brandwatch)

This is quite interesting because if we compare it with the global activity about the speech (the total volume of tweets), we notice that Belgium, and therefore Brussels was the most active country by far :

 
Nb : countries are obtained via data provided by GNIP for Twitter and by the journalist / blogger’s site (Source: Brandwatch)
 

This shows that the EU stakeholders are more active than others. But we also notice that the tweet activity were mostly concentrated in EU Capitals, with 2 exceptions : Catalonia and Scotland, two regions where there are strong discussions about the EU.

 
 

Concerning the language issue, we can see that English remains the most spoken language in EU discussions, followed by French and Spanish.

 
 
Nb : Language repartition via Visibrain

Stakeholder analysis

The President of EU Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, is by far the most mentioned or retweeted user by other stakeholders. Nevertheless, all users in this list are from the EU bubble except Marine Le Pen. There is no big media or civil society represented there. If we cross reference this with Social Media analysis methods, we get this map (before the speech). We can clearly see that, before the speech discussions are polarised around EU institutions and divided by language communities.

The same analysis, after the speech (at 1 PM) shows that the European bubble (in blue), was commented in several different languages. Around the bubble we can see local stakeholders speaking their own languages and from different kind of opposition standpoints (Spanish far-left, for instance).

Conclusion

Jean-Claude Juncker’s speech has been mainly shared and commented within the European bubble, with, this year, a British influence mainly because of Brexit. As Mr Juncker recalled it, one of Europe’s difficulty is to deliver a positive image at national and local levels. We can see through Marine Le Pen’s tweets that national stakeholders have a lot more visibility than the European ones. This is also verified through the presence of other local stakeholders such as accounts related to the Spanish far-left.

And thus this is the main difficulty for the EU; to be able to speak to people who are not listening to you.

 

Methodology

This study has been done with Brandwatch (gathering all social medias and news websites) and Visibrain (only Twitter)

  • On Brandwatch, keywords were “SOTEU OR Juncker OR (Discours Etat union) OR (State UNION speech)” only on the 14/09.
  • On Visibrain, the only keyword was “SOTEU” on the last 24 hours.

Every tool is mentioned on every chart legend.

Thanks to Tony O’Brien for english proofreading.